Cream Highlighter Refill

Not sure where to start? Take the Quiz

Free Dry Brush Cleaner with Orders $99+

Save up to 36% on Starter Staks

Not sure where to start? Take the Quiz

Free Dry Brush Cleaner with Orders $99+

save 11%

Cream Highlighter Refill

4.6
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
376
Click to scroll to reviews
A natural, effortless glow in a cream formula you'll fall in love with.
$16.00 $18.00
Please note: this product is a refill pan only. Stak component not included. Refills are not compatible with the old pink stack.
Ship date of
Release date of
Lightweight & hydrating formula for a dewy glow
Easy to apply & lasts all day long
Ultra versatile - this doubles as a cream eyeshadow!

Add To Your Stak

Free Shipping $65 | Free Travel Mirror Lid $100+

Free concealer shade exchange

If it isn’t a perfect match.

Free 30 days returns

Hassle-free for peace of mind.

Conveniently Portable

Refillable Design

Pittsburgh Based

Conveniently Portable

Refillable Design

Pittsburgh Based

Mindful Formulas

Melts into the skin for a natural finish

Skin-nourishing with ingredients like Myrica Cerifera (Bayberry) Fruit Wax

Infused with coffee seed oil to help look more awake

Add To Your Stak

Free Shipping $65 | Free Travel Mirror Lid $100+

@subtlbeauty

Beauty at the Speed of Life

4.6
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
Based on 376 reviews
Total 5 star reviews: 309 Total 4 star reviews: 26 Total 3 star reviews: 24 Total 2 star reviews: 8 Total 1 star reviews: 9
Slide 1 selected
Reviews Summary
Customers say this cream highlighter has a smooth, creamy texture that glides on effortlessly and blends beautifully. Many appreciate its subtle, natural glow without excessive glitter or sparkle. Users frequently mention its versatility for eyes, cheeks, and lips, with several noting it doubles as eyeshadow. Most find it long-lasting and moisturizing.
89%would recommend these products
Write a Review (Opens in a new window)
376 reviews
  • AL
    Amy L. Q.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cream Highlighter Rosé
    I recommend this product
    What is your skintone? Light
    What is your skin type? Combination
    What is your age range? 31-40
    What shade did you purchase? Rosé
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    4 days ago
    Love

    This is actually a favorite. It's smooth and beautiful I will use it on my lips sometimes even!

    Was this helpful?
  • NJ
    Natalie J.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cream Highlighter Rosé
    I recommend this product
    What is your skintone? Light
    What is your skin type? Combination
    What is your age range? 31-40
    What shade did you purchase? Rosé
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 week ago
    Love at first use.

    I genuinely don't ever want to live without this again. The product goes on so smoothly and sinks in. The shimmer is absolutely beautiful. I will use this year round but I think the rosey pinky bronze will be especially gorgeous in the summer.

    Was this helpful?
  • J
    Jenny
    Reviewing
    Cream Highlighter Rosé
    I recommend this product
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    2 weeks ago
    5 Stars

    Good

    Was this helpful?
  • KE
    Kyle E.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cream Highlighter
    I recommend this product
    What is your skintone? Fair
    What is your skin type? Normal
    What is your age range? 41-50
    What shade did you purchase? Champagne
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    3 weeks ago
    Love the dewy look

    I have always been a fan of highlights and contouring. This creme highlighter is light and gives a fresh dewy glow. I've used some other brands in the past that come off as glittery - this one is not. It also makes a great eye shadow primer!

    Was this helpful?
  • VS
    Violet S.
    Verified Buyer
    Reviewing
    Cream Highlighter Champagne
    I recommend this product
    What is your skintone? Light
    What is your skin type? Combination
    What is your age range? Under 18
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    1 month ago
    I love both of these shades!

    I have Rose and Champagne cream highlighter from Subtl. I originally bought the Champagne and that one gives the perfect amount of shimmer without looking sparkly or too bright. I got the Rose with a mystery stack. I never would have picked it out for myself, but I’m kind of obsessed with it now. It’s a different kind of glow, but I love it with just as much as the other one now! It works with every shade of lip and cheek which was the reason I didn’t buy it in the first place.

    Was this helpful?
Show More